Your Team Already Forgot Last Year’s Gift Card

The $50 gift card lands in the inbox on December 18. It gets spent on gas, or groceries, or the earbuds somebody was going to buy anyway. By the second week of January, nobody remembers who sent it. That is the whole problem with the safest choice in employee holiday gifts. It works, and then it vanishes.

This is not an argument against the gift card. It is an argument that the card and the “same mug for everyone” box are the two weakest options on the table, and that the middle path between them is easier to run than most companies think.

There is a third option: a gift-of-choice employee holiday program. Give employees a curated choice of useful, high-quality physical gifts while keeping the experience easy to administer, consistent with your brand, and practical for remote or multi-location teams.

Learn more about the differences, benefits, and tradeoffs in our guide: Gift Cards vs. Gift-of-Choice Programs: Which Employee Gift Strategy Works Better?

What Makes a Good Employee Holiday Gift?

A good employee holiday gift is useful, high quality, relevant to the recipient, appropriate for a diverse workforce, and easy for the company to deliver consistently.

Price alone does not determine whether a gift succeeds.

PPAI’s consumer research found usefulness to be a major driver of perceived merchandise value, while quality strongly affects how recipients perceive the brand behind an item. In other words, the gift has to earn a place in someone’s life before the logo on it can do much work.

For employers, five factors matter most:

1. Usefulness: Will the employee actually use it?
2. Quality: Does it feel like a gift rather than leftover promotional inventory?
3. Choice: Can employees select something suited to their needs or preferences?
4. Inclusivity: Does the program accommodate different roles, sizes, locations, lifestyles, and traditions?
5. Execution: Can you collect selections, decorate products, package them, and deliver everything on time?

That framework matters more than finding one supposedly perfect product.

If sustainability is an important purchasing factor for your company, our sustainable promotional products buyer’s guide explains how to evaluate materials, product longevity, packaging, and environmental claims without sacrificing usefulness.

Why Gift Cards Remain Popular for Employee Holiday Gifts?

Gift cards are popular because they eliminate decisions.

There are no apparel sizes to collect. No product preferences to predict. No boxes to pack. No shipping addresses to chase. The employee can buy whatever they want, and the employer can distribute the reward quickly.

Employees clearly value that freedom.

Ask employees what they want from employee holiday gifts and the card comes up fast. A 2025 survey of more than 1,000 US workers ranked gift cards as the most popular holiday gift category, ahead of food and drink and outerwear.

Custom Ink’s 2025 employee holiday survey found that 52% would rather pick from several gift options than receive the same item as everyone else. Only 31% wanted the identical gift.

People want a say in what they get, and a gift card looks like the cheapest way to give them one. For the person placing the order, the card wins on effort too. There are no sizes to collect, no shipping addresses, and no “I don’t wear hoodies” email on December 20. One afternoon, one spreadsheet, done.

That is a real case, and it explains why so many companies default to it every year. The trouble is that the card solves your problem, not your employee’s.

Many employees view one-size-fits-all gifting as outdated and that personalization can come from choice, timing, and the message around the gift—not only from printing somebody’s name on a product.

The lesson is not simply that employees want gift cards.

It is that employees want agency.

That distinction gives employers more options.

Gift Cards vs. Physical Employee Gifts: What Companies Need to Consider

Gift cards solve one important problem: they give employees freedom. But they also remove some of the elements that make employee holiday gifts memorable — personal recognition, physical brand connection, and the experience of receiving something chosen specifically for them.

1. Branded Employee Gifts Create Longer-Lasting Brand Connections

Once the balance hits zero, the card is a piece of plastic in a junk drawer or a deleted email. Nothing about it says who it came from. A well-made physical item does the opposite.

PPAI’s 2026 consumer study of more than 3,400 US adults found that 68% say usefulness makes branded merchandise feel valuable, and nearly 90% say high-quality merchandise improves how they see the company behind it. A good insulated jacket with a small logo on the sleeve gets worn to the hardware store for three winters. The card is gone by Valentine’s Day.

For companies investing in branded merchandise, product selection matters as much as decoration. See our guide on promotional products and apparel for examples of how quality, usability, and branding work together.

2. Personalized Employee Gifts Better Match Different Employee Preferences

A $50 card is the same object to the 22-year-old apprentice and the office manager who has been with you for thirty years. It carries no thought. In that same workforce survey, 82% of employees said they would value a gift more if it were personalized in some way.

The bottom of their list was just as telling. Office products and stationery, the pens and desk gear employers love to hand out, ranked among the least wanted gifts. A card skips the part where you show you noticed who someone is.

Modern employee gifting is moving toward personalization at scale.

That does not require manually selecting a different product for every person. Personalization can come from:

• Letting employees choose from a curated gift collection
• Allowing apparel size and color selection
• Offering products that fit different work environments
• Including a personal message from leadership
• Creating branded packaging or gift kits

The strongest employee gift programs do not force one product onto everyone.

They create enough choice for employees to feel considered while keeping the company’s budget, branding, and fulfillment process controlled.

3. Employee Holiday Gifts Create Recognition Moments Beyond Transactions

Redeeming a card is a transaction. Opening a box is an event, and employee holiday gifts should feel like one. That difference sounds small until you watch a crew open shipments in the break room versus glancing at a payroll notification. Only one of those becomes a story people tell at home that night.

A branded package, a personal note, and a useful product can create a moment employees share with their families or coworkers.

This is where custom kitting and fulfillment becomes valuable.

A complete employee gift experience can include:

• Curated merchandise selection
• Branded packaging
• Printed thank-you notes
• Multiple product combinations
• Direct-to-employee shipping

The product creates value, but the presentation creates the moment.

For companies building broader appreciation programs, employee holiday gifts can also support a larger employee recognition strategy.

Gift-of-Choice Programs: The Alternative to Traditional Employee Gift Cards

The middle path for employee holiday gifts is a gift-of-choice program. Your team gets the say they asked for, and each person still ends up holding something with your name on it.

Instead of choosing between:

• A gift card that provides freedom but little brand connection
• A single product that provides branding but may not fit everyone

companies can create a curated collection of useful gifts and allow employees to select what works best for them.

A successful gift-of-choice program connects:

Employee preference → personalized selection → useful product → stronger recognition experience

Brandit can help companies build these programs through curated merchandise, employee storefronts, company stores, custom packaging, and fulfillment support.

What Is a Gift-of-Choice Employee Holiday Gift Program?

A gift-of-choice program lets an employer curate a limited assortment of approved gifts at a defined budget, then lets each employee choose the item that fits them best.

Instead of handing everyone the same product or issuing an unrestricted gift card, the company controls the product quality, branding, and overall experience while employees control their individual selection.

A simple program might include:

• Short menu: Five to eight items at one price point across a few categories, such as outerwear, drinkware, tech, something for the kitchen, and something for the truck
• Pop-up store link or simple order form: Employees pick, size themselves, and enter their own ship-to address, so nobody chases anyone for a sweatshirt size
• Two-week window: One announcement email, one reminder, and then ordering closes
• One kitted delivery: Orders ship home or land at the office in one drop, boxed so the unboxing still feels like a gift

The model connects two things that employers often treat as opposites: employee choice and brand consistency. The company maintains control over the quality and presentation of the gift, while employees receive something that better matches their needs, preferences, and lifestyle.

Why Gift-of-Choice Programs Work Better for Diverse Employee Teams?

This setup solves the problems the card only appears to solve. Sizing is handled because people size themselves. Mixed holiday traditions stop being an issue when you frame the program as a year-end thank-you and keep the menu neutral.

Your field-crew-versus-office problem disappears too. The technician takes the beanie and the 40-ounce bottle while the office manager takes the blanket. And the box still shows up, so the surprise survives.

Brand names matter here. More than three-quarters of employees in that workforce survey said they would appreciate a gift from a name like Nike, The North Face, YETI, or Carhartt more than a generic item. Put the money into the product and keep the logo small. It gets worn more, and it gets seen more.

If you already run a company store, the holiday menu can live inside it. Without one, a simple order form does the job just as well for a single season.

With a curated selection:

• Employees choose products that fit their daily routines.
• Apparel sizing becomes easier because employees select their own sizes.
• Different work environments and lifestyles can be considered.
• Companies maintain consistent branding and budget control.
• HR teams avoid manually managing individual preferences.

Personalization does not always require creating a completely different gift for every employee.

In modern employee gifting, personalization can come from:

• Choice of product
• Size and color selection
• A personal message
• Branded packaging
• A gift collection designed around employee preferences

That is personalization at scale.

Employee Holiday Gifts, Payroll, and Tax Considerations

IRS Publication 15-B treats gift cards as cash equivalents, which means they count as taxable wages no matter the amount. They go through withholding and show up on the W-2. Holiday gifts other than cash with a low fair market value can qualify as de minimis benefits and stay off the paycheck entirely. The option that felt easier in October can turn into a payroll task in January.

This is not tax advice, and the rules on value and frequency have specifics your accountant will want to walk through. Ask before you decide, not after the cards go out.

Employee Holiday Gift Planning Timeline: When Should Companies Order Gifts?

Employee holiday gifts fail on timing more than on taste. Name-brand outerwear inventory thins out by mid-November, and decorators are booked solid through December. Here is the schedule that works:

• Mid-October: Menu locked, price point set, artwork approved
• Early November: Ordering opens with one announcement and one reminder
• Week before Thanksgiving: Orders close and decoration starts
• First two weeks of December: Kits ship home or arrive at the office in one drop

If you are reading this in late September, you have a few weeks of slack. Reading it in November, a curated menu of in-stock items is still possible. A custom kit is not.

If you are planning a highly customized program with special packaging, multiple products, or individual shipments, earlier planning provides more flexibility.

For a complete planning guide, see our corporate holiday gifting timeline.

Employee Holiday Gifts That Get Kept, Used, and Remembered

The real question with employee holiday gifts was never card or no card. It is whether the thing you give is still in someone’s life in March. A gift card answers that question by February.

The good jacket, a bottle that rides in the truck every morning, or a blanket on the couch answers it for years, and every one of them carries your name.

---

Want a menu built around your team? The Brandit team takes on a limited number of holiday programs each fall for New Hampshire companies.

Send us your headcount and a rough price point, and we will put together a curated menu your team can choose from. No pitch, just a list.